Those favouring the unusual stance that Judas was a hero try
to soften the harsh betrayal of Judas by explaining his actions completely away
from the Bible’s simple view that his weakness (love for money) allowed Satan
to enter him. They therefore advance various reasons to make their case.
These people assert
that it was Judas's political expectations that were his downfall. He, like
many Jews of that era, expected the coming Messiah to re-establish a literal kingdom that would remove the hated
Roman yolk. Under Roman occupation at the time where the Jewish people were
under oppression and hardship and were being murdered including children by the
Romans without trial or mercy, the Jewish people believed that the Messiah will
come and lead the Jewish people to a great victory by being a great military
leader. *
Therefore, when there was so much tension under Roman occupation and
Jesus was preaching forgiveness, it's not hard to understand that Judas was
disillusioned with Jesus practicing the opposite to what the Jewish people
expected him to be doing.# With sayings like "Forgive them all", “and
the lion will lie down for the lamb" and "Give to Caesar what belongs
to Caesar"#, Jesus appeared to be a direct opposite to the messiah the
Jews were expecting. They had very high and wrong expectations of the Messiah
at that moment.
Despite all that Jesus said to tell them how wrong they were
(consider the parable of the mustard seed
as an example - inauspicious and almost unseen beginnings of the kingdom), the
disciples were slow to understand that Jesus' kingdom was not of this world*,
and importantly, it was not yet time for the kingdom of the world to be
restored to the Messiah and to the Israelites.
Consequently, it might seem Judas was trying to force Jesus'
hand - to get him to present himself as the Messiah in a political way.* He
might have thought Jesus would employ his miraculous powers to resist the
oppression of the Roman authority and to some extent the hypocritical religious
leaders of the day if he is forced to do so.
Others also reason that Judas believed in his cause and
would probably have thought like most Jews do today that Jesus was not the
messiah. But he was not the only one to lose his faith either. The other disciples as well as Judas himself
might not fathom how the Messiah could die the death of
a common criminal? Only on Jesus' resurrection did they believe again. But then, Judas
had already taken his life. #
So, would Judas be forgiven?
Jesus could have forgiven him. He was certainly sorry for
what he had done. The man committed suicide in his grief. And Jesus forgave the
men who drove the spikes into Him, didn't He? **
Peter denied Christ but repented later and "wept
bitterly". Peter had the faith that Jesus would forgive him for his lack
of confidence. Judas did repent. But instead of putting his faith in Jesus'
mercy and His power to forgive, he passed his own judgment on himself by
hanging.*
However the gravity of the offence committed in these two sharply different scenarios remains in serious dispute though they all involve an unquestionable act of betrayal.
However the gravity of the offence committed in these two sharply different scenarios remains in serious dispute though they all involve an unquestionable act of betrayal.
Judas could have asked for forgiveness instead of dooming
himself by hanging. It was his betrayal that was condemned not his life. Jesus understands
and would still want him saved since people, nay, sinners like Judas was one of the reasons He came
down. But instead, he hanged himself and that made him twice the betrayer he
already was. Not very heroic.#
- #wiki.answers.com
- *answers. Yahoo.com
No comments:
Post a Comment